
Tomorrow night on Mythbusters, Adam and Jamie are going to tackle this question:
“A plane is standing on a runway that can move (some sort of band
conveyer). The plane moves in one direction, while the conveyer moves
in the opposite direction. This conveyer has a control system that
tracks the plane speed and tunes the speed of the conveyer to be
exactly the same (but in the opposite direction). Can the plane take
off?”
That one question has been debated across the internet, in airports, over drinks all across the country.
Well, I'm going to give you the answer early, in my own special way.
OF COURSE THE DAMNED PLANE TAKES OFF.
First let's look at it as a thought experiment:
When you run on a conveyor belt tuned to the same speed you're running, you won't move forward relative to the ground. When you drive a car on a hypothetical conveyor belt tuned to the same speed as the car, the car won't move forward relative to the ground.
What you're supposed to think is that the plane won't move forward relative to the ground if it's on the conveyor belt. But the plane has an important distinction compared to your feet and your car. Both you and your car propel yourself along because of the force you exert against the ground. The airplane exerts force, through propellers or jet engines against the air, the tires are not powered - not in any way. There is no motorization tied to wheels on any aircraft I've worked on or around. Those wheels spin freely and are there just to reduce friction against the ground. The skis on amphibious aircraft are proof of that. A plane can take off on a relatively calm river either upstream or downstream. What's more important is the direction of the wind, not the direction of the water.
Said another way: The plane doesn't care what's below it, so long as there's free airflow to create lift through the pressure differential on the two wing surfaces.
What's going to happen is that the conveyor and wheels will keep going faster and faster in free spin, until the plane leaves the ground, but that plane is going to be propelled down the conveyor runway by it's engines, not by its wheels.
Recent Comments